Hentai protagonist
Gallery
Even if you were to classify Mysterious Girlfriend X as hentai (which I would disagree with, but still) would that disqualify it from being a legitimate work? Forest is a Japanese visual novel that contains multiple scenes of occasionally shocking pornography, but not only would I classify it as an excellent work of popular literature but would also venture to say that not a single character in the game is what you might label a “faceless protagonist.”
As for you comment about how hentai could be a legitimate work. I would agree on principle. However, I think this falls under the differing if-then lines of logic. On one hand, not all hentai or sexually based work is shallow or uses what I have termed the “faceless protagonist”. However, those series that do use faceless protagonists are more than likely a shallow work. MGX thus far being a notable exception.
I’m not sure I agree with you about Tsubaki being a “faceless protagonist”. (I find his name easy to remember because “tsuba” is spit :P, also it’s mentioned in show that his name means camellia.) Maybe it’s because I generally avoid hentai shows like the plague so I’m not noticing the telltale signs of the trope, but to me he just seems like a protag with a fairly conventional personality (i.e. timid and harmless). I thought the first two episodes introduced us to him and his quirks as much as Togabe’s, except she was just more extreme.
I try not to make a habit of watching a lot of hentai themed shows anymore as they’re mind numbing. Still, from what I remember, a lot of the protagonists are timid, and, in the real world, would never get access to the women in their respective shows. Faceless protagonists allows some people who watch these shows, with these personalities, to imagine themselves in the protagonist’s lfe. This is why a lot of eroge don’t show the main characters faces. Otherwise, its like the character is wooing the girl(S) in the game, and not the person playing it.
Now that I think about it, I’d hardly say that the “faceless protagonist” is limited to eroge or hentai. Contemporary anime is full of bland male leads who exist solely to play counterpart to quirky female characters. The kind of stuff produced by J.C. Staff on a regular basis strikes me as the worst offender, but it’s hardly exclusive to just them. I think you could argue, for example, that Shuu from Guilty Crown is faceless. Amata from Aquarion EVOL is faceless as well. Often these characters are more complex than immediately apparent, and occasionally the author pulls a hat trick and creates a legitimately excellent character in that mold (see Araragi in Bakemonogatari,) Akira in MGX, actually, strikes me as an example where enough sympathy was invested in his character that he comes off as an everyman rather than as a vessel for the viewer. That generally is not the case with most anime in this mold.






